IME - Education Project Conferences

Teaching and the patient who lacks capacity - Is it ethical? Is it legal?

Venue: Cardiff University
Date:  Thursday 24 June 2010
Programme: pdf

Programme

A key aim of the IME three year Education Project on learning, teaching and assessment in undergraduate medical ethics, is to foster and facilitate a sense of community between teachers of medical ethics and law and to support learning.

Consideration of the legal and ethical issues in respect of teaching using patients who lack capacity may provoke a difference of opinion. Does the Mental Capacity Act 2005 enable the teaching of medical students using patients who are unconscious, and where it has not been possible to get prior consent, using 'best interests' as a justification?

The focus of the morning session will be a 'Mock Trial'. Professor Penney Lewis (King's College London), representing P, a patient, is seeking a declaration that Andrew Tillyard, (I.T.U Consultant, Peninsula Medical School) has been unlawfully teaching medical students using unconscious patients without having first elicited their consent. A number of 'expert witnesses' will be called to represent different perspectives including that of the GMC, a patient and an F1/medical student.

In the afternoon session workshops will enable discussion of ethical and legal issues arising in different clinical settings where patients are unable to give consent to their involvement in medical student teaching: Mental Health, Learning Disabilities, ITU, Care of the Elderly and Surgery. Each workshop will address the following:

  • What are the problems in this area of teaching?
  • How can the interests of patients be safeguarded?
  • How do you teach using patients in this category?


Booking and information

There is no charge for the conference for participants. The IME is very keen to welcome clinical and non clinical teachers of ethics and law. Places are limited to a maximum of 60.

Please book by emailing Elaine Paris, Joint Project Manager, IME Education Project:
educational@instituteofmedicalethics.org
 
Further details can also be obtained from Elaine Paris.

 

Reports of Previous IME conferences

2006, 2008, 2009, and 2010